Quality of Life With a Stoma in Daily Life

Does living with a stoma feel the same throughout the day, or does it change depending on where you are and what you are doing?

Living with a stoma involves daily care, from emptying and changing the appliance to looking after the surrounding skin. It can also mean planning outings around access to toilets and supplies. These demands can affect quality of life and confidence in managing a stoma (self-efficacy).

However, most previous studies measured these outcomes at a single point or months apart. They offered little insight into how quality of life and confidence might change throughout the day, or how they relate to a person’s location, activities, and company.

To explore these changes, researchers measured both outcomes three times a day for a week. Sixty-two adults with a bowel stoma answered short surveys through the Avicenna app (then Ethica), each time reporting where they were, what they were doing, and whom they were with. To the authors’ knowledge, this was the first study to use ecological momentary assessment (EMA) to examine quality of life and self-efficacy in people with a stoma.

The study was conducted by the School of Medicine at the University of Leeds, with co-authors from NHS Highland and the University of Dundee. Recruitment ran from April 2021 to March 2022, as the United Kingdom was emerging from COVID-19 lockdowns. The study formed part of William Goodman’s PhD research.

Plan your sample size around both the number of participants and the repeated responses your planned analysis needs, then account for the surveys participants may miss and those who may drop out before data collection begins.

Study at a Glance

Study feature Detail
Study design Observational EMA study, 7 days
Population Adults in the United Kingdom with a bowel stoma (ileostomy or colostomy)
Participants 62 completed the study (69% female, mean age 51, range 19–77); 77% had an ileostomy
Reasons for stoma formation Inflammatory bowel disease (53%), cancer (32%), and other reasons (15%)
Recruitment Social media (X and Facebook), emails to charity and support group members, and newsletter adverts
Recruitment period April 2021 to March 2022, fully remote
Schedule 3 surveys daily at 9 a.m., 1 p.m., and 7 p.m.; each available for 2 hours
Total possible responses 21 surveys per participant
Measures Location, activity, and company; quality of life and self-efficacy, each rated on a 0–100 scale
Response rate 1,057 of 1,302 possible surveys completed (81.2%)
Compensation £10 Amazon gift voucher for completing at least 17 of 21 surveys
Tools Online baseline survey, Avicenna app (then Ethica) for timed surveys, and SPSS for analysis
Ethics approval University of Leeds Medicine and Health Ethics Committee (MREC 20-043)
Funding William Goodman: Economic and Social Research Council White Rose Doctoral Training Partnership; Rebecca Beeken and Matthew Allsop: Yorkshire Cancer Research; and Amy Downing: Cancer Research UK

How the Study Worked

Designed With People Who Live With a Stoma

Before applying for ethics approval, the research team discussed the study with a steering group of patients, nurses, and representatives from charities and industry. The group provided feedback on survey timing, the number of surveys, and question wording to make sure the questions were clear and manageable for participants.

Baseline Survey and App Setup

Everything happened remotely. Participants first received a link to an online baseline survey about their stoma, health, and background. It collected information such as stoma type, how long they had had it, the reason for its formation, age, gender, and long-standing health conditions.

After completing the baseline survey, participants received step-by-step instructions for downloading and registering in the Avicenna app. The researchers selected the app because of its compliance with data protection regulations, its use in previous research, its suitability for EMA studies, and its ability to support fully remote data collection without face-to-face contact. Participants were encouraged to contact the research team promptly if they experienced problems with the app.

Three Surveys a Day

Participants received three surveys daily, at 9 a.m., 1 p.m., and 7 p.m., allowing the researchers to capture changes across the day. Surveys started the day after participants registered, and each remained available for two hours to give participants flexibility around their schedules.

Each survey began with three questions about the participant’s current situation:

  • Location: At home (including working from home), at work, traveling, shopping, at a friend’s or relative’s house, out for recreation, in a health care setting, or other.
  • Activity: Working, commuting, exercising, shopping, relaxing, socializing, doing housework, or other.
  • Company: Family or partner, friends, colleagues, alone, or other.

Participants then answered two questions using sliders ranging from 0 to 100:

  • Quality of life: “We would like to know your overall satisfaction with your life in general right now.” This question was adapted from the Stoma Quality of Life Scale.
  • Self-efficacy: “At this moment right now, how confident do you feel that you can do the different tasks and activities needed to manage your stoma right now?” This question was adapted from an EMA study in another population.

The researchers used single questions for both measures to keep the surveys short and reduce the burden on participants.

Planning the Sample Size Around Survey Responses

Because the analysis used repeated measurements, the team needed to consider both the number of participants and the number of repeated responses. The steps below describe how they planned this study, not a general rule for EMA sample sizes.

Start with the data points needed. The team drew on previous research suggesting that EMA studies using multilevel models should aim for more than 900–1,000 data points. Reviews of earlier EMA studies also helped the researchers estimate a reasonable participant count.

Account for missed surveys. Each participant could complete 21 surveys over seven days. Assuming an average response rate of 80%, the team expected around 17 completed surveys per participant. To collect more than 1,000 responses, they needed at least 59 participants.

The target was met. Sixty-two participants completed the study, providing 1,057 responses out of 1,302 possible surveys (81.2%). This worked out to just over 17 completed surveys per person. Missed responses were distributed almost evenly across morning, afternoon, and evening.

The compensation threshold also reflected the expected response rate: participants received a £10 Amazon gift voucher if they completed at least 17 of the 21 surveys.

Recruitment required additional planning. Reaching 62 participants who completed the study involved 104 people initially contacting the research team. Of these, 87 completed the baseline measures, and 62 went on to complete the EMA protocol. This shows why planning for missed surveys is only part of sample-size planning: researchers also need to account for people who do not reach the data-collection stage.

What the Study Found

The researchers used multilevel models to examine both changes within individuals over the week and differences between participants.

Both measures fluctuated within individuals. Approximately 35% of the variation in quality of life and self-efficacy reflected changes within the same person over the week. The remaining variation reflected differences between participants. This shows why measuring these outcomes only once may miss fluctuations over time.

Confidence was lower outside the home. Participants reported lower confidence in managing their stoma when they were outside the home than when they were at home. However, the size of this association varied considerably between individuals. The authors suggest that familiar surroundings and access to the facilities and supplies needed for stoma care may help explain the difference.

Quality-of-life scores were higher later in the day, on average. Compared with morning scores, quality-of-life scores were, on average, 2 points higher in the afternoon and 4 points higher in the evening. The authors suggest that sleep disturbances, including waking during the night to change a stoma appliance, may help explain lower morning scores. They recommend including sleep quality measures in future EMA studies.

Confidence and quality of life were associated. Participants who reported higher average self-efficacy over the week also tended to report higher quality of life. Within individuals, moments of greater confidence were also associated with higher quality-of-life scores.

Activity and company showed no significant associations. Whether participants were relaxing or engaged in more demanding activities, and whether they were alone or with someone else, was not significantly associated with either measure. Older participants reported higher quality of life, while a longer time living with a stoma was associated with lower quality-of-life scores.

The authors suggest that future self-management interventions could offer support when people need it most, particularly outside the home. Since the relationship between location and confidence differed between participants, such support may also need to be tailored to individual circumstances.

The researchers also note several limitations. The study took place as COVID-19 restrictions were being lifted, which may have influenced the findings. Online recruitment and the requirement for smartphone access may have resulted in a sample that was younger and less representative of the wider stoma population. Finally, the use of single-item measures reduced participant burden but did not capture every dimension of quality of life and self-efficacy. The measures also lacked defined thresholds for clinically meaningful differences.

In Their Words

We asked William Goodman, the first author of the study, about running it.

What advice would you give researchers planning a similar EMA study with a patient population recruited and run entirely remotely?

“My main advice would be to plan the whole participant journey, from the first expression of interest through to completing the final survey. Keeping questionnaires short is important, but people also need to understand what is involved, get started with the app and fit repeated surveys into their everyday lives.”

“Involving people with lived experience early is particularly valuable. Our steering group helped us consider the timing and frequency of surveys and the wording of questions. Clear instructions and an accessible route to researcher support are also important. Running a study remotely still requires attention to the human support that makes participation possible.”

Was anything about running this study, particularly keeping participants engaged from first contact through to the app, easier or more difficult than you expected?

“I was pleasantly surprised by how well older participants engaged with the study. There can be an assumption that older people will be less comfortable with digital technology, but that was not necessarily reflected in my experience. I think the streamlined, user-friendly app helped make participation accessible. It reinforced the importance of not making assumptions about someone’s ability or willingness to participate based on their age.”

“The other lesson was the distinction between initial interest and actually getting started. Some people expressed interest and completed the baseline questionnaire but did not progress to the EMA stage. We cannot be certain why each person did not continue, but this is something researchers should allow for when planning recruitment. Once participants were taking part, survey completion was encouraging: the EMA sample completed 81.2% of the scheduled surveys.”

Looking back, what did Avicenna make possible that would have been difficult to do otherwise?

“Avicenna enabled us to collect repeated, in-the-moment reports while participants went about their everyday lives. We could schedule three short surveys each day, with a defined response window, without requiring face-to-face visits or manually contacting everyone at each assessment.”

“That allowed us to examine fluctuations within individuals and explore how confidence and quality of life related to their immediate circumstances, something that a one-off questionnaire would not have captured.”

“Affordability was also important. The team worked with me to find an arrangement that was achievable within my PhD research budget. Having access to this functionality at an affordable price made a real difference to what I could deliver as a doctoral researcher.”

Research Team

William Goodman, PhD
First author
University of Leeds

Rebecca J Beeken, PhD
Corresponding and senior author
University of Leeds

Other co-authors: Matthew Allsop and Amy Downing (University of Leeds), Julie Munro (NHS Highland), and Gill Hubbard (University of Dundee).

Publication

Ecological Momentary Assessment of the Quality of Life and Self-Efficacy Among People With a Stoma: Longitudinal Study. Goodman, W., Allsop, M., Downing, A., Munro, J., Hubbard, G., & Beeken, R. J. (2025). Journal of Medical Internet Research, 27, e57427.

Planning a Similar Study?

This study shows how repeated, short surveys can capture changes in people’s experiences that a one-time questionnaire might miss. By combining a few questions about the participant’s current situation with brief outcome measures, researchers can examine how experiences vary across time and context without placing too much burden on participants.

Avicenna supports several elements of this study design:

  • Scheduled surveys: Time Triggering Logic can deliver surveys at fixed times throughout the day.
  • Flexible response windows: Expiry Time lets researchers define how long a survey remains available after it is triggered.
  • Context questions: Single Answer and Multiple Answer questions can collect information about participants’ location, activities, and company.
  • Repeated outcome measures: Visual Analog Scale (VAS) questions allow participants to rate their experiences using sliders.

For researchers interested in building on this study’s findings, Avicenna also supports geofencing. This can trigger surveys when participants enter, remain in, or leave a defined area. Such triggers could be explored in future studies investigating context-aware support for participants outside their homes.

Related resources:

For questions about study design, data collection, or the right setup for your research, explore Avicenna’s features and integrations or talk to our team.